Russell Hantz
Winner
Finalist
5* Votes To Win
Krista Klumpp
2nd Place
Finalist
4 Votes To Win
David Murphy
3rd Place
Finalist
1 Vote To Win
Stephanie Valencia
4th Place
Juror
2-2 Vote
Tiebreaker
Ralph Kiser
5th Place
Juror
4-1 Vote
Kristina Kell
6th Place
Juror
Voted Out Ep. 11, Pt. 1
3-3-2 Vote
4-2 Revote
Phillip Sheppard
7th Place
Juror
Voted Out Ep. 11, Pt. 2
6-1 Vote
Julie Wolfe
8th Place
Juror
Voted Out Ep. 12
4-2 Vote
Natalie Tenerelli
9th Place
Juror
Voted Out Ep. 10
5-4 Vote
Matt Elrod
10th Place
Juror
Voted Out Ep. 9, Pt. 2
4-3-3 Vote
Ashley Underwood
11th Place
Juror
Voted Out Ep. 8
5-5-2 Vote
6-4 Revote
Grant Mattos
12th Place
Juror
Voted Out Ep. 9, Pt. 1
8-3 Vote
Francesca Hogi
13th Place
Pre-Juror
Medevaced Ep. 7
Rob Mariano
14th Place
Pre-Juror
Voted Out Ep. 5
4-4 Vote
4-2 Revote
Andrea Boehlke
15th Place
Pre-Juror
Voted Out Ep. 2
5-4 Vote
Mike Chiesl
16th Place
Pre-Juror
Voted Out Ep. 4
4-3 Vote
Sarita White
17th Place
Pre-Juror
Voted Out Ep. 3
7-1 Vote
Steve Wright
18th Place
Pre-Juror
Voted Out Ep. 1
7-2 Vote